Match Thread [AET] Celtic 3 - 3 Rangers (Bajrami 41'; Diomande 75'; Danilo 89')

[ranger_syntax 4,422]

39 minutes ago, CammyF said:

Here's the exact moment we lost the cup final in my opinion.

That was a great chance to win it.

 

You can find the exact moment we lost in the penalty shootout.

[Bluedell 5,679]

1 hour ago, CammyF said:

Here is IFAB rule 12  ;

"If a defender starts holding an attacker outside the penalty area and continues holding inside the penalty area, the referee must award a penalty kick."

But play is stopped when the ref blows his whistle. I don't have a clue when he did blow it, but if it was immediate and before the defender went into the box then VAR can't intervene. However in saying that, it happened so quickly that I find it very unlikely that was the case and doubt the whistle was blown immediately.

[CammyF 8,370]

26 minutes ago, Bluedell said:

But play is stopped when the ref blows his whistle. I don't have a clue when he did blow it, but if it was immediate and before the defender went into the box then VAR can't intervene. However in saying that, it happened so quickly that I find it very unlikely that was the case and doubt the whistle was blown immediately.

As you say, the incident happened / developed that quickly, it's hard to imagine Bearon blew for a foul before Cerny was in the box. 

 

I'm sure we'll get the audio to clear things up. If Beaton has blown then it's an error on him, as you are meant to allow play to develop and then make your decision.

 

Also, I don't know why he'd have blown before Cerny has his shirt/shorts pulled. The video clips show Cerny was in the box when this initiated, then fell out of the box. In my opinion that's why Beaton gave a free-kick and not a penalty (understandably).

 

 

[Bluedell 5,679]

(3) John Walker on X: "Penalty Narrative Dismissed - Beaton Whistles after play stops - It was for the pull (that was inside the box) - Freekick taken from Edge of Box (Not the corner where some are claiming) https://t.co/zXz73ueXJL" / X

 

Not sure why the above link doesn't embed, but it shows clearly that the whistle goes AFTER play stops so there's no reason for VAR not to intervene.

[CammyF 8,370]

9 minutes ago, Bluedell said:

(3) John Walker on X: "Penalty Narrative Dismissed - Beaton Whistles after play stops - It was for the pull (that was inside the box) - Freekick taken from Edge of Box (Not the corner where some are claiming) https://t.co/zXz73ueXJL" / X

 

Not sure why the above link doesn't embed, but it shows clearly that the whistle goes AFTER play stops so there's no reason for VAR not to intervene.

And sometime after Cerny hits the ground. So another honest mistake that'll be swept under the (bulging) carpet. 

 

As for VAR, I think we all know why it didn't intervene. 

Edited Monday at 14:43 by CammyF

[compo 7,184]

2 hours ago, CammyF said:

Here's the exact moment we lost the cup final in my opinion.

 

 

Total lack of footballing awareness aye I said it to Dolly our cat that miss will come back to haunt us .

[RANGERRAB 3,731]

That’s 2 Cup finals in a row this year Beaton has won for the yahoos (he was on VAR in the SCF)

let that sink in……

[CammyF 8,370]

14 minutes ago, RANGERRAB said:

That’s 2 Cup finals in a row this year Beaton has won for the yahoos (he was on VAR in the SCF)

let that sink in……

See what happens when you put pressure on them? They are terrified to give us a decision. 

 

The "Penalty to Rangers" campaign has also worked a treat. 1 penalty awarded domestically this season. 

 

However, there are still Rangers fans happy for us to ignore this (one on here but I think he's a troll more than a fan) and continue to watch us cheated week in, week out. The silence from the board shows they appear to be willing to ignore this.

 

Let that sink in.......

Edited Monday at 15:30 by CammyF

[RANGERRAB 3,731]

2 minutes ago, CammyF said:

See what happens when you put pressure on them? They are terrified to give us a decision. 

 

The "Penalty to Rangers" campaign has also worked a treat. 1 penalty awarded domestically this season. 

 

However, there are still Rangers fans happy for us to ignore this (one on here but I think he's a troll more than a fan) and continue to watch us cheated week in, week out. The silence from the board shows they appear to be willing to ignore this.

 

Let that sink in.......

Nothing will change until we get a high profile CEO will to confront the SFA, SPFL and them too. Whether Patrick Stewart is willing to step up and do that remains to be seen.

[CammyF 8,370]

4 minutes ago, RANGERRAB said:

Nothing will change until we get a high profile CEO will to confront the SFA, SPFL and them too. Whether Patrick Stewart is willing to step up and do that remains to be seen.

With so many ex-referees now posting their thoughts on social media immediately after games, I'd employ one of them and get them posting via our social media platforms highlighting these clear and obvious errors / honest mistakes.