Jump to content

 

 

DMAA

  • Posts

    5,065
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    27

Posts posted by DMAA

  1. 17 minutes ago, Gonzo79 said:

    From what I gather, Dundee Utd are decent going forward but not great at the back, which is all the more reason to attack them at every opportunity.  Winning is all that matters but I really want to thrash this lot.

    Their centre back Connolly had a howler against Kilmarnock, stuck with the ball at his feet. For context, he was signed from Crawley Town. Their other centre back is Mark Reynolds who is obviously very experienced and can be trusted at this level. At left back they have a kid and a new signing from Argentina so I think we could target that area. At right back they have Liam Smith (ex Rangers youth) who has a lot of experience for his age (24), contributes a lot going forward but I've no idea what he's like defensively.

  2. 1 hour ago, ranger_syntax said:

    Really?

     

    3 percent returns and mostly due to sizing, no?

     

    How many strips made it to customers successfully?

     

    The problems are real. Maybe this is another vocal online minority skewing perceptions though.

    I have followed the threads on Follow Follow and the sheer volume of complaints is hard to argue with. And it is from reputable people on the forum too including the admins, some of whom bought the most expensive gear on the website and still had to return it all due to quality issues. I am a bit skeptical of the 3% figure to be honest.

     

    The biggest complaint I have is stock. Every time I check, they don't have anything in stock that wouldn't fit the incredible hulk, unless you buy from Ashley. Celtic on the other hand have everything in stock all the way from infants to adults in their own online shop as well as JD Sports. The stock issue will cost the club and Celtic will make very good money out of the service they are getting from Adidas. The appetite for the new kits wanes quickly as the season goes on.

  3. Quote

    "They came in with their fee, half of what Brentford paid, their pitch was ‘listen, we’ll just wait to January, and in January we will pre-sign him and you won’t get a pound note. "When you try and negotiate with me like that, all you do is f****** wind me up. I wasn’t born yesterday, I’ve been around the business a long time, that’s probably over £60m worth of transfers I’ve done since I bought Peterborough United.

    Another target missed due to Liewell's biscuit tin. Good on this guy for having the guts to expose them too. Hope it hurts their reputation with owners down there.

  4. 4 minutes ago, craig said:

    Newell is pish and Kamberi spent the second half of the season at us.  Horgan has always looked decent, but still not good enough for Rangers - which also means Middleton would struggle.

     

    Would I like the lad to come good ?  Absolutely - but for a Gerrard team he is too one-dimensional.

    The point is they are mostly experienced players who are much older and it’s always going to be hard to displace them when you are only on loan and a kid, it doesn’t mean you simply aren’t as talented. 
     

    He was only really given 9 games. With Kamberi, as I said, Jack Ross froze him out the minute he came in. You can’t judge Middleton for that. Newell was a 26/27 year old Heckingbottom signing so obviously he was going to give him plenty game time. 
     

    The conclusions being drawn from his time at Hibs are incredibly simplistic. 

  5. I forgot to mention that the primary reason for Middleton not succeeding at Hibs was Heckingbottom's sacking. He was signed by Heckingbottom and he was always in the matchday squad and making appearances under Heckingbottom. He didn't make a single matchday squad after Heckingbottom left. Jack Ross froze him out for reasons only he knows. There was every chance he would have come good once he had bedded in and injuries and suspensions gave him a run in the team. Very few young wingers can come in and immediately displace experienced players 6-7 years older than them (he was competing with Kamberi, Newell and Horgan for the left forward spot).

     

    I should be his agent.

  6. 13 minutes ago, Rousseau said:

    Nah. Speed-merchant. :D 

     

    I think you're exaggerating his ability, in what were fleeting appearances, but I agree with the general argument. I thought he was a very good prospect, but didn't show it consistently. He's still only 20, so I hope he can improve to force his way into the picture. 

    Just to be clear, I agree that the sample size is small and that is a caveat on my comments. However, what I was primarily trying to get across is that he showed that he did have the ability to do things other than knocking the ball 10 yards ahead of him and getting round his man. I think of a Gregg Wylde when people say speed merchant and he never showed the ability that Middleton did.  

  7. 2 hours ago, Frankie said:

    It's like you say, Gerrard wants his forward players to be two-footed and able to interchange right across the final third.  Kent, Barker and Hagi are two footed so the best current options for this.  Jones and Middleton are more traditional wingers so have perhaps struggled more to adapt/impress in training.  Someone like Stewart is another good option but he's quite left-sided and lacks the pace of the other current first choices.

    I think this is the main reason he has been frozen out, Gerrard likes a certain type of player to play in his system. It would be easier to understand if he'd been on the fringe but he has been totally frozen out.

     

    It feels pointless debating Middleton because it's clear as day he has no future here, but he still gets a bad rap so I've been baited by the speed merchant label so I'm going to defend him one more time. He has shown time and time again he has a lot more than just pace to his game. We only saw glimpses of him in all honestly, but here are some examples.

     

    He is a very good crosser, his corners were consistently pinpoint. Do people not realise the technique involved in that? Far more consistent than Tavernier or Kent. His in-game crossing was very good too. One example that people will remember is his 90th minute assist for Morelos to clinch the game at St Johnstone. An excellent cross, and it was something he did often, not a one off. How often have we seen any of our attacking midfielders put a cross like that on Morelos's head in the 6 yard box? I can pretty confidently say almost never, they just don't do it and sometimes you need a conventional, quality cross instead of running into traffic over and over again.

     

    He showed at Villareal with a well weighted through ball to Barisic that he has the vision to play a good through ball. That was a "secondary assist" but he got praise for it at the time. 

     

    He also consistently showed that he is actually a very good finisher and one of the best at shooting from range that we have. His finish at home against Motherwell was excellent and it was at the end of the box and even on his weak foot. For someone so one footed he has done something I don't think anyone in our current team has done (bar Morelos once at Aberdeen), score from outside the box on his weak foot. Surely most people have seen his rocket against Celtic youths in the final too. I don't think anyone in our current team is capable of scoring from 30-35 yards with that kind of power. He had another excellent finish from the edge of the box in that game too.

     

    I am not saying he should be starting, that ship has sailed, but he has been under-utilised and consistently underrated by some of our fans and I think he will go on to have a good career somewhere else.

  8. 1 minute ago, der Berliner said:

    Looks like Josh Windass will move to Sheffield Wednesday and as part of that deal we'll finally receive the 500k Wigan still owe us from his move in 2018.

    Great news, every little helps. Along with the clearing out of fringe players and probably Alfredo soon, it all hopefully paves the way for a couple of quality signings in the coming weeks.

  9. 32 minutes ago, craig said:

    I am not sure how Middleton gets so much credit as a player.  Not only does he have little more than speed, but he couldnt break into a mediocre Hibs team last year - I dont think that is good enough for Rangers. 

    I always backed him in the 18-19 season but I don't know what has happened. Loans can easily go wrong, especially at one of the better sides in the league, but why hasn't he gone anywhere this season. It is strange. 

  10. Entertaining read, thanks. Plenty to be positive about. I think there are one or two missing pieces to the jigsaw that the sale of Morelos can hopefully bring about. If we could bring in a quality attacking midfielder with proven end product we would be in a really good place. 

  11. 1 hour ago, Frankie said:

    Still think it could have been worse.  We drew Midtjylland at that point last season and disposed of them comfortably enough....

    We would go into each game as favourites. It's purely a matter of how likely an upset would be, and these are strong teams for this stage of the competition. We have a benchmark of sorts in that we've played against teams from these leagues last season.

     

    Rio Ave - 5 points behind Braga in 5th

    Willem II - 6 points behind Feyenoord having played 1 game more, in 5th

    Lech Poznan - 3 points behind Legia in 2nd

    Hammarby - No benchmark, but finished a point behind Djurgarden, who lost 2-0 to Ferencvaros. In 7th so far this season after 18 games

     

    Away from home the first three in particular would be tricky. Rio Ave the main team to avoid I think. But we are definintely favourites. 

  12. Rangers
    Progrès or Willem II
    Borac Banja Luka (BIH) or Rio Ave (POR)
    Hammarby (SWE) or Lech (POL)

    CELTIC
    KuPS (Fin) or Slovan Bratislava (SVK)
    Riga (LVA) or Tre Fiori (SMR)
    Sileks (MKD) or Drita (KOS)

    ABERDEEN
    Budapest Honved (HUN) or Malmo (SWE)
    Sport Lisbon (POR)
    PSV (NED)

    MOTHERWELL
    Backa Topoloa (SRB) FCSB (ROU)
    Osiejk (CRO) or Basel (SUI)
    Lac (ALB) or Hapoel Beer-Sheva (ISR)
    IFK Goteborg (SWE) or Copenhagen (DEN)

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.