Jump to content

 

 

Scott7

  • Posts

    11,430
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    44

Posts posted by Scott7

  1. 2 hours ago, 26th of foot said:

     

    Hibs had more than Stanton and Cropley deserving of a cap, John Brownlie, John Blackley, and Jimmy O'Rourke were most deserving

    A vintage Hibs team. O’Rourke deserved to be in it after the mediocrity alongside him at the start of his career.

  2. 25 minutes ago, ChelseaBoy said:

    Good stat, but i suppose Fergie saved a fair bit by having Scholes, Beckham, Giggs, Sharpe, Butt, the Nevilles, Wes Brown, Fletcher, O'shea, Evans and Wellbeck come through, whereas Wenger struggled after the defence he inherited got old and the replacements were poor.  

    Does that show that AF is the better manager?

  3. 18 minutes ago, Rousseau said:

    t's quite unusual for a manager to leave us

    Very true. The exceptions are Souness and Wallace, first time,  sort of. He went down in terms both of geography and status to Leicester though that was more to do with not being given what he needed at Ibrox rather than a burning desire to join a great club admired since childhood. 

  4. John Prentice the flukey, offside equaliser in a benefit match v Elgin City 1952.


    For the first competitive goal, I was sure it was Derek Grierson but checking the record it was in fact John Prentice again v Thirds Glasgow Cup Final 1953. 

  5. 3 hours ago, Gonzo79 said:

    Sean Dyche.

    Claudio Ranieri.

    Roberto Mancini.

     

     

     

    I see what you’re getting at. Mancini opened the door for Guardiola to slip through.

     

    How would the magic circle of managerial wizards get on at keeping Burnley in the top division for years? Not so well, I fancy.

     

    How would Dyche get on at City or Chelsea? We’ll never know.

  6. 1 hour ago, Bill said:

    first convenient and palatable opportunity

    Correct. I think that’s what I was trying to say. He would have gone to ‘Spurs if he’d been invited but not, for example, Brighton or Palace. It’s a risk for him but he must think the risk of finishing second to celtic is greater.

  7. 5 minutes ago, PoohBear said:

    Villa though, I can't think of a more mediocre EPL club.

    Brighton, Palace, Southampton, Norwich, Watford, Brentford, even Leicester. Some are above Villa in the table currently but together they don’t have Villa’s potential.

     

    Fair to say, though, that some notable managers have failed to unleash that potential.

  8. That looks right except drop Mourinho back to fifth place because of his destructive tendency. Guardiola could overtake Ferguson and Tuchel’s coming up fast on the rails but he may not be a stayer. The new runner from Villa Park has a lot of hard furlongs before Rodgers is even in sight.

  9. 2 hours ago, CammyF said:

    What we should be worrying about is not the departure of SG, but who replaces him. Maybe just coincidence but SG leaving so soon after terrible financial results being posted, has alarm bells ringing.

    Respect to a Throstle.
     

    I agree with your post except the quote. Finance will have been on his mind but I don’t think that’s prompted his departure. Aston Villa is the causal factor. He wouldn’t be leaving for Palace, Southampton or Brighton. See my reply above to Ian.

  10. 2 hours ago, ian1964 said:

    I just can't see why he would want the Aston Villa job just now tbh? he would best served staying @ Ibrox at least until his contract is up and building his reputation, especial in Europe!.

    It's a huge risk taking on the Aston Villa job on IMO, if they get relegated and on a bad wee run then theses billionaire types are quick to replace managers

    He knows he won’t go straight to Anfield from Ibrox without having won a European trophy. He knows that’s not going to happen. He doesn’t have to do that at Villa, just get them playing well and threatening the top four in the league and good cup runs. No trophy needed because in the eyes of EPL clubs good performance in  the EPL is all that’s needed.

     

    If you take Arsenal, City, Liverpool and Chelsea as the top four, only Villa, Newcastle, ‘Spurs and Everton and possibly Hammers, have the resources for a consistent challenge. Conte got the ‘Spurs job. Newcastle are too big a risk this season. West Ham don’t really have it. He’s never going to Everton. Villa’s his best chance. He may fail hopelessly but there’s a greater prospect of hopeless failure at Ibrox where hopeless failure is defined as finishing second behind celtic.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.