alexscottislegend

Yep, but sometimes players have to be dropped for their own good. Even Rooney is left out occasionally by Fergie. Do we really need Barry for games ve St Mirren or Killie? (no disrespect)

Fergie is showing signs of tiredness no doubt; normally he'd be first on the team sheet IMO. Let's leave him out for some league games, say v the likes of Kilmarnock or St. Mirren. Even Rooney's omitted from Man U from time to time.

After watching Spurs go out on penalties last night after being the better side, I'm starting to get nervous. If - God forbid -we had to go to pens. would you trust this line-up? Nacho, Fergie, Davis, Adam, and Boyd. That's the best pen line-up I can think of, and with McGregor v Wiese in goal, we'd have a chance!

Anybody else heard the rumour Walter will sign him in summer? Can't for the life of me see why. Does that mean there is a serious long-term doubt over Steven Smith? If he's just for back-up, then we've already got Papac and Whittaker for LB

Juffery's spot on. We don't need ANYONE who sees us and 2nd choice. BARDSLEY may be better then McNaughton or alexander, but we have Whittaker as back-up and then maybe even Broadfoot?

Now look: this is a straightforward honest question. Yes, he's been inconsistent in the past, yes, he's had injuries - but he seems now to be fit. SO - WHY does Buffel not merit a start - ESPECIALLY since he'd fit beautifully into a 4-5-1? After all, he played that way at Feyenoord. And if he is on his way out - who should we go for to replace hime - give the midfield that bit of "continental class"?

Agree with most of the posters. Miller had his chance but ruined it with that badge-thumping nonsense. Anyway, where did the story come from? Is WS REALLY thinking of it? Derby want �£2m Surely there must be someone better we can spend that cash on?